Putting on my breaker's hat for a moment, if we were at roughly $600 in cards for the last order, what about something like this...
2013 Topps Triple Threads (4 hits)
2013 Panini Absolute (4 hits)
2012 Topps Valor (4 hits)
2012 Panini Crown Royale OR Limited (4 or 3 hits respectively)
2011 Panini Absolute (4 hits)
That'd be roughly the same cost, via Blowout. It's not Five Star, but Triple Threads, Absolute and Valor isn't a terrible sub by any means.