Would you send this back to Topps for replacement?

[Molitor04x]

Got this nice Tigers card from 2022 Triple Threads but the top right corner is dinged. My gut is to send it back to Topps to try to get a replacement card but do you think I’m being too picky? -Ryan

 

[Criollos]

I think you are entitled to it, but I wouldn’t go through the trouble.…..contacting them, mailing it, waiting, and waiting, and waiting, and who knows what you may receive in return.

 

[Mechjo16]

That is a NICE card!

 

[dubby25]

I have been told from them that they would replace anything that is not considered an 8 or above. Not sure if this qualifies, so they may send it back. However, worst case is they send it back (or it gets damaged in the mail). Depends on the risk you want to take. Personally, if I have a card /27, the grade is not such a big deal, there are still only 27 of the cards, regardless of the shape it is in.

 

[Prosefan1]

Topps has stated that they will not replace cards that they feel wouls grade an 8 or higher. Cant remember where I read that but at the time I remember thinking that it was legit!!