Upper Deck replacement mail. Not sure how I feel about it

[ar1888]

I pulled a Donald Brown 2 color Sp Authentic patch with some chipping on it. I was told I could trade card for card. They sent me these instead. They said my card did not meet replacement standards. If it didnt meet the standards, I wish they would have just sent it back. I made it clear I wanted a Donald Brown for Donald Brown.

2009 Spx winning materials 3 color patch 21/99

2006 Rookie debut Reggie Wayne/Sinorice Moss Dual auto

Stephen McGee Sp Authentic patch. I love this patch, but think I would rather have my Donald Brown patch back.

 

[Poopy Pants]

You would be surprised. That Mcgee could probably fetch 25-30 on ebay, and the average 2 color Brown is going for 30-35. I think you did alright. You might not be happy with it, but you could make it work.

 

[ar1888]

You would be surprised. That Mcgee could probably fetch 25-30 on ebay, and the average 2 color Brown is going for 30-35. I think you did alright. You might not be happy with it, but you could make it work.

The McGee patch looks even better in person then on the scan. I just dont know If I want to go through all the trouble of putting it up in EBay. I hate dealing with that crap. I just hate getting a card numbered 999, for a card numbered 499. if they would have sent a Browb Sp back with these cards I would be dancing a Irish jig.

 

[bamasa37sb34]

Think those 06 Rookie Debut autos are SP to 20, so that's cool at least...... and nice black and red Manning patch

 

[scotsman]

You won there IMO

 

[sliqwill]

flip it and buy a different one :salut:

 

[Brad]

I bet that Manning swatch is really a Leinart one.

Good thing on the dual is that Miami has some fans so I think you came out ahead CV wise, but I would rather just have the Brown.

 

[lumm0x]

I too think you did okay. Hopefully you can flip without too much trouble and get what you want.

 

[sffanmike25]

Tough break on not getting the kind of replacement you wanted

 

[AUTaxMan]

When did Manning play for the Falcons? They must have stuck an Alge Crumpler in there by mistake.

 

[deimos]

looks like they are gonna have to replace the manning.
they did decent job imo.

 

[ar1888]

The manning is from a pro bowl jersey according to the list of cards on the bottom of the return letter.

 

[bamasa37sb34]

I bet that Manning swatch is really a Leinart one.

Good thing on the dual is that Miami has some fans so I think you came out ahead CV wise, but I would rather just have the Brown.

Check out their home game crowds, then get back to me on Miami football fans. Kthxbye :run:

 

[andy]

You won there IMO

I really think you did well on this. Much better than I have ever done on a redemption.