Football Rating drafts from 2001-2005 ! Example Inside..

[#11 Roy Williams]

2002:

1 Houston David Carr QB Fresno State - B
2 Carolina Julius Peppers DE North Carolina - A
3 Detroit Joey Harrington QB Oregon - C
4 Buffalo Mike Williams T Texas - D
5 San Diego Quentin Jammer CB Texas - C+
6 Kansas City Ryan Sims DT North Carolina - D
7 Minnesota Bryant McKinnie T Miami - D
8 Dallas Roy Williams SS Oklahoma - B+
9 Jacksonville John Henderson DT Tennessee - B+
10 Cincinnati Levi Jones T Arizona State - F
11 Indianapolis Dwight Freeney DE Syracuse - A
12 Arizona Wendell Bryant DT Wisconsin - F
13 New Orleans Donte' Stallworth WR Tennessee - A
14 N.Y. Giants Jeremy Shockey TE Miami - B+
15 Tennessee Albert Haynesworth DT Tennessee - B
16 Cleveland William Green RB Boston College - D
17 Oakland Phillip Buchanon CB Miami - B-
18 Atlanta T.J. Duckett RB Michigan State - C-
19 Denver Ashley Lelie WR Hawaii - D-
20 Green Bay Javon Walker WR Florida State -A
21 New England Daniel Graham TE Colorado - C-
22 N.Y. Jets Bryan Thomas DE Ala.-Birmingham - D
23 Oakland Napoleon Harris OLB Northwestern - D
24 Baltimore Ed Reed SS Miami - A+
25 New Orleans Charles Grant DE Georgia - F
26 Philadelphia Lito Sheppard CB Florida - B
27 San Francisco Mike Rumph FS Miami - F
28 Seattle Jerramy Stevens TE Washington - C
29 Chicago Marc Colombo T Boston College - D
30 Pittsburgh Kendall Simmons G Auburn - F
31 St. Louis Robert Thomas OLB UCLA - F
32 Washington Patrick Ramsey QB Tulane – C

 

[Tha1thereis]

I'm just wondering why Hutchinson is a B in most of your lists when hes the highest paid guard and most likely the best in the NFL.

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

2003 NFL DRAFT:
1 Cincinnati Carson Palmer QB Southern California - A
2 Detroit Charles Rogers WR Michigan State - F
3 Houston Andre Johnson WR Miami – A
4 N.Y. Jets Dewayne Robertson DT Kentucky - D
5 Dallas Terence Newman CB Kansas State - B
6 New Orleans Johnathan Sullivan DT Georgia – F
7 Jacksonville Byron Leftwich QB Marshall – B-
8 Carolina Jordan Gross T Utah - F
9 Minnesota Kevin Williams DT Oklahoma State - D
10 Baltimore Terrell Suggs DE Arizona State - C
11 Seattle Marcus Trufant CB Washington State - C
12 St. Louis Jimmy Kennedy DT Penn State - D
13 New England Ty Warren DE Texas A&M - D
14 Chicago Michael Haynes DE Penn State - F
15 Philadelphia Jerome McDougle DE Miami - F
16 Pittsburgh Troy Polamalu SS Southern California – A
17 Arizona Bryant Johnson WR Penn State - C
18 Arizona Calvin Pace DE Wake Forest - C
19 Baltimore Kyle Boller QB California – D-
20 Denver George Foster T Georgia – F
21 Cleveland Jeff Faine C Notre Dame - F
22 Chicago Rex Grossman QB Florida - A
23 Buffalo Willis McGahee RB Miami – B+
24 Indianapolis Dallas Clark TE Iowa - B
25 N.Y. Giants William Joseph DT Miami – C-
26 San Francisco Kwame Harris T Stanford - F
27 Kansas City Larry Johnson RB Penn State – A+
28 Tennessee Andre Woolfolk CB Oklahoma - C
29 Green Bay Nick Barnett MLB Oregon State - C
30 San Diego Sammy Davis CB Texas A&M - F
31 Oakland Nnamdi Asomugha CB California - F
32 Oakland Tyler Brayton OLB Colorado – F

 

[paintballbando00]

Thats the same thing with Carr....some of you would rate him a D....but if he was on a winning tweam, you'd say the pick was a B or an A

its really not a legit system, becuase i t is a team sport

so all of your grades have to have some lee-way

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

But he is the QB... supposed to make the team better than they are if he is really that good..

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

2004 NFL DRAFT:
1 San Diego Eli Manning QB Mississippi A-
2 Oakland Robert Gallery T Iowa D
3 Arizona Larry Fitzgerald WR Pittsburgh A
4 N.Y. Giants Philip Rivers QB North Carolina State A
5 Washington Sean Taylor FS Miami B
6 Cleveland Kellen Winslow TE Miami C+/B-
7 Detroit Roy Williams WR Texas A
8 Atlanta DeAngelo Hall CB Virginia Tech A
9 Jacksonville Reggie Williams WR Washington C-
10 Houston Dunta Robinson CB South Carolina C
11 Pittsburgh Ben Roethlisberger QB Miami, O. B+
12 N.Y. Jets Jonathan Vilma MLB Miami B
13 Buffalo Lee Evans WR Wisconsin B
14 Chicago Tommie Harris DT Oklahoma A
15 Tampa Bay Michael Clayton WR Louisiana State D
16 Philadelphia Shawn Andrews G Arkansas D
17 Denver D.J. Williams OLB Miami D
18 New Orleans Will Smith DE Ohio State D
19 Miami Vernon Carey T Miami F
20 Minnesota Kenechi Udeze DE Southern California D
21 New England Vince Wilfork DT Miami C
22 Buffalo J.P. Losman QB Tulane C+
23 Seattle Marcus Tubbs DT Texas D+
24 St. Louis Steven Jackson RB Oregon State A
25 Green Bay Ahmad Carroll CB Arkansas D
26 Cincinnati Chris Perry RB Michigan D
27 Houston Jason Babin OLB Western Michigan D
28 Carolina Chris Gamble CB Ohio State C
29 Atlanta Michael Jenkins WR Ohio State C
30 Detroit Kevin Jones RB Virginia Tech B+
31 San Francisco Rashaun Woods WR Oklahoma State D
32 New England Ben Watson TE Georgia B+

 

[jasonbay]

Your going to drop Ben Roethlisberger 2 grades because of a bad yr . Do you not remember the rookie who didnt lose in the regular season and led us to AFC championship and led us to the SB victory. I think that speaks for itself now im just wondering what would have given Rivers last year seeing never played? Also Vilma a C are insane , 108 , 173 and this yr 91 . You wonder those numbers represent and that my friend would be tackles nuff said A status granted . Chris Gamble 15 ints in first yrs so far deserves atleast a B .Reggie Williams 9th overall and gets B- with stats like 27-268-1td , 35-445-0td , 32-371-4td.. Do you look at any stats or do randomally spout letter and sometime add a dash at the end . C to Michael Jenkins now is being generous . Shawn Andrews would have him atleast C breaking his leg his rookie season sucked for him . Rashaun Woods has 7 career catchs and hasnt caught one since 2004 and you give him a D on what hopes and dreams ? Chris Perry you wrote some potensial ...yeah he has some potensial to get hurt ...lol

 

[balance13]

i also don't like your Chris Perry grade.

sure he has some potential but he's neveer going to get to play

 

[balance13]

and what the heck does chris Gamble get a D for

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

I changed some, because I have time. That was a quick rush through. But, if you look at it, some of them I gave lower grades because of their high pick, and the people who were drafted behind him...

If you look at some of these teams, and they drafted a DL when they need a RB and Steven Jackson was there, they shouldn't get that high of a grade unless they are one of the premiere of their position.. like Jackson.

 

[jasonbay]

Wait so this is theory . A teams something else o lets say a QB and they draft hmmm a LB . So you dock LB grades because the team didnt do what was best for the team. Your theory is flawed and not accurate.

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

Your grammer is flawed and inaccurate...
Time in sentances so I can understand you. But, from what I got is that I am putting down LBs grades because there is a QB? No, if they need a QB and not a LB but take a LB, like the Lions do with WRs, I won't boost the grade of them because they were takin' before what was needed..

Calm down, it's just a fun little project..

Sorry that my opinions don't match up with you.

Chill.

 

[jaguars06]

I must ask Stroud D, C?

Yet Leftwich a A-? Think it should be the other way around.

 

[jaguars06]

Reggie Williams a C? Should be a C-

Eli Manning a A-? He is killing the Giants right now, should be Lower.

 

[jasonbay]

Your grammer is flawed and inaccurate...
Time in sentances so I can understand you. But, from what I got is that I am putting down LBs grades because there is a QB? No, if they need a QB and not a LB but take a LB, like the Lions do with WRs, I won't boost the grade of them because they were takin' before what was needed..

Calm down, it's just a fun little project..

Sorry that my opinions don't match up with you.

Chill.

Attacking my grammar ..haha . Im not saying you should boost either . Thats what I got out of your post . It shouldnt have anything to with the team . Its about players. If you want to have a teams draft grade thread now thats a different story