Football Eagles' McNabb hurt on 3-yard touchdown run

GotGibson?

Bench Warmer
Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb has gone to the locker room with an injury suffered on a short touchdown run against the Carolina Panthers.

McNabb scored on a 3-yard run in the third quarter to give the Eagles a 38-10 lead. He didn't immediately get up after the touchdown, and was attended to by Eagles trainers before eventually leaving the field on his own.

Trainers seemed to be checking his lower back or ribs before he headed to the locker room.

While he was on the ground, quarterback Michael Vick was captured on TV standing in a stadium suite to watch McNabb. Vick is suspended for the first two regular season games to complete penalties for bankrolling a dogfighting ring.

McNabb was replaced by Kevin Kolb.
 
McNabb uncertain for Week 2 with cracked rib

Donovan McNabb once played four quarters on a broken ankle. A cracked rib can't keep him out.

Can it?

"He's pretty sore," coach Andy Reid said Monday. "He's going to try and battle through it. He'll struggle to practice. He's going to do everything he possibly can to try to play. We'll see how that goes. He's staying optimistic about that."

McNabb is not ruling himself out for the Eagles' game against New Orleans next Sunday.

"Not necessarily, anything can happen. It's just Monday right now, but if Friday and Saturday come along and I'm feeling a lot better, you just never know," he said. "It's a slow process of just meeting with our trainers, doing two-a-days with treatment, going through the process of just like I'm playing in the game, and seeing how I feel at the end [of the week]."

Third-year pro Kevin Kolb filled in for McNabb during Philadelphia's 38-10 victory over Carolina in the season opener. He would start against the Saints if McNabb can't play.

Michael Vick is not eligible because he was suspended for the first two regular-season games as the last part of the NFL's penalty for his role in a dogfighting ring. Vick probably wouldn't start even if he could play because he's still rusty and Reid has maintained all along that Kolb is the backup.

Kolb hasn't moved the offense much in the few opportunities he's had, though he's never worked with the starters during a practice week. The Eagles could find themselves in a shootout against Drew Brees and the rest of New Orleans' high-octane offense, so they can't afford a slow start.

"I have full confidence in him," Reid said of Kolb. "I don't worry about his accuracy or knowledge of the offense right now. It's just a matter of getting caught up with the game speed of the regular season."

The Eagles don't have a fourth QB on their roster, so they'll need someone to back up Kolb if McNabb can't play. A.J. Feeley, who was 4-3 filling in for McNabb in 2002 and 2007, is a logical choice to be re-signed. Feeley was released on Sept. 6.

"We have a lot of respect for A.J. but I know other people in this league do, too," Reid said.

McNabb got hurt when he took a hard shot on a 3-yard TD run in the third quarter. He spun away from a defender at the goal line, but was nailed by Panthers nose tackle Damione Lewis on the ground in the end zone.

"I can't say anything on that," Reid said. "You get those 300-plus pound guys motoring and it's hard to stop. Sometimes they come in a little bit late."

The NFL reviewed the play and ruled the hit was "not illegal," spokesman Greg Aiello said in an e-mail.

"It's a rough game. We're not clamoring about Josh McCown. I mean he got whacked pretty good, too," Panthers coach John Fox said after reviewing the tape. "It's tough. I'm sorry he got hurt. I don't ever like to see any player get hurt, our team or theirs. It's unfortunate."

McNabb played an injury-free season last year for the first time since leading the Eagles to the Super Bowl in 2004. He's missed 24 games, including playoffs, due to injuries during his first 10 seasons in the NFL. The Eagles are 14-10 in those contests.

Reid said McNabb doesn't have to practice to play this week.

"We've seen him do that before and play some pretty good games," Reid said. "We'll take it day by day. We just want to get him back healthy."

Reid isn't concerned that McNabb could exacerbate the injury by playing.

"It's broken. I don't think you can make that part worse," Reid said. "We just have to see how he can function. I'm not going to put him out there if he can't function.

"Rib injuries are all different. This one's displaced a little bit and pretty painful. I know other guys have played with broken ribs. They're all different. It's hard to compare."

If it's simply a matter of pain tolerance, as often is the case with broken ribs, McNabb proved a long time ago he's a tough guy. He broke his right ankle in the first quarter against Arizona on Nov. 17, 2002, stayed in and threw four touchdown passes. McNabb missed the next six games, but returned for the playoffs.

He sat out the final seven games in 2005 with a sports hernia and a torn ACL cost him the last eight games in '06, including the playoffs. McNabb didn't play two games in 2007 because of ankle and thumb injuries.

"Donovan is resilient," teammate Brian Westbrook said.
 
just picked up Garcia is it me or are we actually trying for the superbowl. I'm all about every move they have made thus far.
 
McNabb getting better; status still iffy

Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb did not practice Wednesday because of his cracked rib and it is still not known if he will play against the New Orleans Saints.

"He's making some progress," coach Andy Reid said. "It's too early to say anything right now. We'll just see how he does here over the next couple of days."

Kevin Kolb took snaps with the starters Wednesday. Reid again made it clear that Kolb will start against the Saints if McNabb can't play.

Jeff Garcia, picked up by the Eagles on Tuesday, would be Kolb's backup. He will be the No. 3 emergency quarterback if McNabb starts.

Michael Vick and Garcia will share snaps running the scout team this week. Vick is not eligible to play until next week against the Kansas City Chiefs.

McNabb cracked a single rib when he was crunched by several defenders on his 3-yard touchdown run in the third quarter of last week's win at Carolina. He didn't immediately get up after the touchdown and was attended to by Eagles trainers before eventually leaving the field on his own.

Reid said McNabb's ribs need to get "sticky" -- or, not move up and down -- before he should play.

Kolb has never started an NFL game or thrown a touchdown pass.

"This is his opportunity to present to the rest of the league what he's all about," Garcia said. "Hopefully he takes advantage of all of that."
 
McNabb doing all he can to play Sunday

The Eagles are holding out hope that quarterback Donovan McNabb might be able to play in their home opener against the New Orleans Saints.

Eagles offensive coordinator Marty Morninweg said before Thursday's practice that McNabb has been "working hard" and "doing everything in his power to get back out there."

McNabb fractured a rib on a touchdown run late in the Eagles' 38-10 win over Carolina last Sunday. He was on the practice field for the team's walkthrough Thursday morning, but did not partake in it.

If McNabb does not play Sunday, third-year quarterback Kevin Kolb would make his first NFL start. Kolb was the team's second-round draft pick in 2007.

Veteran quarterback Jeff Garcia, signed Tuesday, would be the backup.
 
Rib leaves McNabb doubtful for home opener

Kevin Kolb took all the snaps with the first team in practice. He answered all the questions about his preparedness to start for the Eagles.

Kolb was publicly supported by his teammates, and kept his cool even as Jeff Garcia was signed as their backup QB.

He's done it all this week but start his first NFL game.

Kolb appears set to get that welcomed chance against New Orleans on Sunday. Donovan McNabb was listed as doubtful because of a fractured rib and sat out practice for the third straight day Friday.

The Eagles haven't completely ruled out McNabb, leaving open the slim chance that the quarterback who once threw four touchdown passes on a broken ankle can gut out a painful rib injury against the Saints.

McNabb bellowed "I feel great" and laughed as he left the Eagles locker room. Coach Andy Reid said there was a chance McNabb would participate in Saturday's walkthrough.

"He felt a little bit better today and we'll just keep rehabbing him and see how it goes the next couple of days," Reid said.

Kolb, who has never thrown a TD pass in eight career games, is ready to start.

In an interview on the Jim Rome radio show, Eagles receiver DeSean Jackson said Kolb would start.

"In my mind, I'm the starter," he said. "That's the way I have to think of it."

Kolb would get the start ahead of Garcia, who signed Tuesday as an emergency backup. Garcia would be the No. 3 emergency QB if McNabb could somehow play. Michael Vick, suspended for the first two regular-season games as the final league penalty for his role in running a dogfighting ring, is not eligible until Week 3 against Kansas City.

Garcia and Vick shared snaps running the scout team Friday.

Reid has faith in Kolb, the Eagles' second-round draft pick in 2007.

"He takes charge in there and he's done a nice job with managing the huddle and the plays," Reid said.

It has been a strange sight for sure at Eagles practice this week, where McNabb, Garcia and Vick mingle in the background while Kolb runs the offense. Three QBs with a combined 12 Pro Bowls and six NFC title games are reduced to cheerleaders for Kolb and his 167 career yards passing and four interceptions.

Kolb said he was more comfortable at each practice and knows he's ready to handle the Saints and the rest of the NFL.

"I had about 12 people come up to me and say, 'God, you look as ready as you'll ever be," Kolb said. "Now it's about going out there and making sure it happens."

He has to make it happen because the fans will demand a change if he gets off to a slow start. Garcia was an instant fan favorite during his first stint here when he led the Eagles to the NFC East title subbing for an injured McNabb. Kolb has already been told he's earned the chance to start and finish Sunday's game.

There are no guarantees he'll get a second start no matter the result. With Garcia and Vick lurking if McNabb can't go against the Chiefs, the pressure is amped on Kolb to play well and win.

If Kolb throws three interceptions and the Eagles are down 17 entering the fourth quarter, why not try Garcia? He wished Kolb well, but said he's prepared to play if pressed into action.

"I'd be fired up," Garcia said. "If for some reason that opportunity presented itself, I'll be ready. I'll be ready to go."

Then again, Kolb could shine, McNabb could rush back and struggle, and those fickle fans could be chanting "We want Kolb!" on Oct. 11.

McNabb cracked a single rib when he was crunched by several defenders on his 3-yard touchdown run in the third quarter of last week's win at Carolina. He didn't immediately get up after the touchdown, and was attended to by Eagles trainers before eventually leaving the field on his own.

Kolb was 7 for 11 for 23 yards and sacked twice once he took over for McNabb.

Reid said McNabb's rib has become "sticky" -- or, more stable -- which was encouraging.

"When they start feeling better, that's normally a sign that's happened," he said.

McNabb laughed at his locker when asked about his sticky ribs.

"I don't know what that means," he said. "I never heard that in all my life."

He's not the only Eagle hurting. Eagles defensive end Victor Abiamiri missed Friday's practice with a groin injury and was listed as questionable.

Safety Quintin Demps, guard Todd Herremans and linebacker Joe Mays are all out Sunday.

They know their fate. Kolb wants a concrete answer on his role.

"Yeah, as soon as possible just because you want to know," Kolb said. "It doesn't matter because I'm preparing right now like I'm the starter. My mindset is that I'm starting and that's the way I have to think of it."
 
Back
Top