Your top 10 NFL QBs ever?

[andy]

1.Terry Bradshaw
2.Ben Roethlisberger
3.Bobby Layne
4.Dick Shiner :salut:
5.Bubby Brister
6.Neil O'Donnell
7.Tommy Maddox
8.Mark Malone
9.Dennis Dixon
10.Charlie Batch

No Kordell?

 

[DTownTigers87]

1.Terry Bradshaw
2.Ben Roethlisberger
3.Bobby Layne
4.Dick Shiner :salut:
5.Bubby Brister
6.Neil O'Donnell
7.Tommy Maddox
8.Mark Malone
9.Dennis Dixon
10.Charlie Batch

Hate the Squeelers, but ASU Alumni = :cheers::dance::salut::clap: in my book.

 

[ar1888]

1.Joe Montana-All he did was win
2.Johnny Unitas- One of 2 players on my list I never watched.(legend alone)
3 Brett Favre-Like him or not he is a part of NFL history.
4.Peyton Manning-You can interchange Peyton and Brady here if you like.
5.Tom Brady-See Manning comments.
6.John Elway-Had a lot of injuries towards the end of his career, but went out on top.
7.Dan Marino-Never won the big one, but left with almost every passing record there was.
8.Warren Moon-I wish we could know what his stats would look like if he where in the NFL his whole career
9.Terry Bradshaw-He won 4 Super Bowls.
10.Fran Tarkenton-See Marino comments

 

[GiantFan]

Am I the only one that thinks Brady should be in the 10 area? I just don't think he is THAT great. One of the best of HIS generation but I don't think one of the top5 all-time. Maybe when all is said and done he will be but I don't see it right now.

 

[DNoz29]

Am I the only one that thinks Brady should be in the 10 area? I just don't think he is THAT great. One of the best of HIS generation but I don't think one of the top5 all-time. Maybe when all is said and done he will be but I don't see it right now.

I thought I'd get dinged for being biased against him if I did that. :eh:

 

[andy]

I hate Brady but he did win several Super Bowls without a lot of offensive playmakers.

I also don't see how noone but me has even mentioned Otto Graham. Played 10 seasons, 10 title games appearances, 7 championships.

 

[ar1888]

I hate Brady but he did win several Super Bowls without a lot of offensive playmakers.

I also don't see how noone but me has even mentioned Otto Graham. Played 10 seasons, 10 title games appearances, 7 championships.

I thought about him, but I tried to stay away from players I was too young to ever see play. With the exception of Unitas, and Tarkenton. It was a diffrent game back then and its hard for me to put a QB who has more INT the TD on my list when I never saw him play.

 

[andy]

I thought about him, but I tried to stay away from players I was too young to ever see play. With the exception of Unitas, and Tarkenton. It was a diffrent game back then and its hard for me to put a QB who has more INT the TD on my list when I never saw him play.

Very true. It was a much different game, but I have trouble not getting behind someone who was probably the biggest winner in football history.

 

[thepistonsfan]

1) Johnny Unitas
2) Joe Montana
3) Sammy Baugh
4) Brett Favre
5) Peyton Manning
6) Dan Marino
7) Fran Tarkenton
8) Bart Starr
9) Tom Brady
10) Heath Shuler

 

[oregonweim]

Of QBs from my nearly 4 decades in life.... (in no particular order....)

*Marino
*Elway
*Favre
*Manning (need I say which)
*Fouts
*Moon
*Montana
*Kelly
*Young
*Brees