Football Who is the best player ever to play?

[pcag]

Who is the best player to ever play in the NFL?

Name your top 5 of all time

 

[ac-n-mike]

in NO particular order... and remember I am a NBA guy... NOT a NFL guy...

JIM BROWN
JOE MONTANA
JERRY RICE
WALTER PAYTON
BARRY SANDERS

ITS A TOUGH 5.... CAUSE UNITAS, BAUGH, LT, NITCHZKE AND A FEW OTHERS ARE GOOD ARGUMENTS AS WELL

 

[HiEnd]

Jim Brown
Lawrence Taylor
Walter Payton
Joe Montana
John Elway

 

[ac-n-mike]

you GOTTA have Jerry Rice in the top 5... thats against the law isn't it? LOL

 

[HiEnd]

Thought about that,but the problem was,who comes out.

LT has to be there. He's arguably the greatest defensive player ever.

Montana and Elway to me are 1 & 1a for the greatest QB's ever,and Sweetness/Jim Brown speak for themselves

 

[Pee632]

I would say
Gale Sayers
Jerry Rice
Brett Farve
Lawrence Taylor
& Sweetness it should have been 10

 

[iLikePie]

in no order...

jerry rice
walter payton
brett favre
barry sanders
lawrence taylor

 

[tigsfan]

Moving this from the IP discussion area to the football area...

 

[pcag]

mine in order is

Jim Brown
lawrence taylor
Jerry Rice
Joe Montana
Barry Sanders