Question on a high end Walter Payton trade!

[#11 Roy Williams]

I will trade my:

1998 Topps RC Reprint Walter Payton BGS 9.5 Auto

for


1998 Topps RC Reprint Walter Payton Auto and $600

 

[BrownieBites]

If it were me I would keep the original.

 

[rexvos]

do it.

 

[andy]

I would be very tempted to do it, depending on what you paid, and seeing a nice scan of the ungraded card and deeming it NM.

 

[metallikat87]

do it.

i would do that a million times

I would be very tempted to do it, depending on what you paid, and seeing a nice scan of the ungraded card and deeming it NM.

this is also important but you know it wont grade as high or he wouldnt do the trade
if the high grade is important you need to think about it but if you just want to have a payton auto i dont see how you can turn it down

 

[BrownieBites]

Derr... I'm retarded... Trade it.

 

[lumm0x]

i would do that a million times

x100000000

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

Whoa. reading it again, i just realized i messed up :doh:

I will be trading for the BGS 9.5

so, from what i gather, i shouldn't do it? i wasn't really thinking on doing it, because $1200 does seem a bit steep, but i wasn't for sure since none have ended recently.