I don't mind Hamels, Sheets or Smoltz making it over Maine. Sheets and Smoltz are the aces of their teams and the NL needed some LHP (which is how Brian Fuentes made it, I guess... what a joke).
Maine is having a good season, but Sheets and Smoltz have been doing it for a while. Hamels is one of the best young LHP in baseball.
As much as it pains me to say it, Zo is right with Young getting screwed. I couldn't believe it. Brandon Webb, Derek Lowe, Ian Snell, Tom Gorzelanny and Tim Hudson all have strong cases for the ASG, to go along with Maine. They can't get everyone on the team, though.
I'm thinking they should expand the rosters to 35 players to avoid some of the snubs and making sure there are enough pitchers to finish the game.