Opinions wanted on Donruss replacement

[Wise4671]

Hi,
I sent a Darren McFadden Contenders rc auto in to Donruss for a replacement because it had a dinged corner and the auto ran off the sticker. I was told that they did not have a Mcfadden replacement and that they would send me out something of equal value and this is what I got

Seems fair enough to me but want to know what you all think.

 

[cwells52]

BV wise it is ok as the McNabb books more, but I would personally rather have the D-Mac

 

[Willage]

I'd take that replacement anyday.

 

[canesfan2011]

you made out way better imo the D-mac was nice but he hasnt proven himself yet McNabb is a star and has a crazy following

 

[BGT Masters of Tiki D]

Its a nice card I think you did better.

 

[zoeman1999]

much better card...

 

[Wise4671]

Thank you all for your input I think I did pretty good on this one

 

[dsizemore]

Definitley a better card. You made out like a bandit. In 2 years McFadden may not be worth $5 and the McNabb will always have a nice value.

 

[Moosehead]

agreed, steal!

 

[dsizemore]

Is this card available for trade?

 

[bazookajojo]

wow.. donruss must hate me...
everytime i have a replacement they screw me soooo bad...
thats a nice mcnabb... you did really good there.. i guess it might be because i hate the raiders though.. lol

 

[atrain2004]

time will tell on dmac but as far as replacement does anyone else find it weird that they have 1999 stuff to give out as replacements? so how many dmcnabbs do they have sitting and how many were really made then!