of current players how many do you think are all time greats?

[scrappy]

yeah gotta say harrison and edge should definately make that list, busted knees and all

 

[rexvos]

yeah gotta say harrison and edge should definately make that list, busted knees and all

both are not on rosters.

Dawkins is a tough one for me, because I really like him, but it hurts him that Polamalu has 2 Super Bowl rings, not that automatically makes him better but the defense was solely responsible for the 1st one, and he like Ed Reed always make huge plays at critical moments.

 

[Seahawcla]

I dont consider Edge great, just really good. He is not in the realm of the players listed. I think Champ might be good enough the more I think about it.

 

[vetsgt02]

Kurt Warner. He has been to 3 SB and had greta numbers in hsi career.

 

[Zeeck]

Lorenzo Neal

Second

 

[dnabb8436]

Kurt Warner. He has been to 3 SB and had greta numbers in hsi career.

Wouldn't exactly say he has had great stats. He has played in the NFL 12 years. In those 12 years he has passed for 28.5k yards and 182 Touchdowns. Peyton Manning who has also been in the NFL for 12 years has passed for 45.6k yards and 333 touchdowns. So I would say Warner has good numbers while Manning has great numbers.

 

[vetsgt02]

Wouldn't exactly say he has had great stats. He has played in the NFL 12 years. In those 12 years he has passed for 28.5k yards and 182 Touchdowns. Peyton Manning who has also been in the NFL for 12 years has passed for 45.6k yards and 333 touchdowns. So I would say Warner has good numbers while Manning has great numbers.

Very good point. :salut: