Not a 9.5 based on the scans. However, that could easily be made a 9.5 (as nats proved). Bgs allows 1/16â€ deviation in card sizes- that is a nice bit of room for roto tillers and the other tools used by card doctors. Not saying it is right, but that is the way the game is played when grading cos. allow for size deviations and allow people who routinely get subs kicked for trimming to keep submitting. buy the card, not the holder. buy from people you trust.