Baseball Instant Replay: Should it be instated??

[Johan Santana #57]

With all of the blown HR/Not HR calls over the last weeks, instant replay has gained some fervor. What is your stance on it? Should it be a part of the game for Fair/Foul and HR Calls?

I think so, the game is already long enough, 5 minutes isn't going to make a big difference! And as long as the call is right, thats what counts.

 

[dbackfan12]

I dont like it because a machine would take away a mans job. I mean first it will start at hr calls. Then steal calls. Then close plays. Eventually it will take the place of an umpire. People are not perfect and we should not be replaced just because we make a mistake every now and then. I mean hitters only are perfect 30% of the time usually and we rely on umpires to be 100% right so they need a break every now and then too.

 

[Bryan_Mc]

I dont like it because a machine would take away a mans job. I mean first it will start at hr calls. Then steal calls. Then close plays. Eventually it will take the place of an umpire. People are not perfect and we should not be replaced just because we make a mistake every now and then. I mean hitters only are perfect 30% of the time usually and we rely on umpires to be 100% right so they need a break every now and then too.

well played, jesse!

i think they should leave it in the hands of the umpires