Football Fantasy Football Trade Opinions

[SQ180]

Okay fellow freaks, please reply with your opinion.

I have been offered this trade:
I send - Steve Smith, WR Carolina I recieve - Brett Favre

My current QB situation:
Matt Cassell
Carson Palmer - what is his deal

My current WR situation:
Roy Williams
Steve Smith
Laveraneous Coles
Anthony Gonzalez
Justin Gage

After this week I should be 2-2 (didn't start till the second week of the season).

 

[Johan Santana #57]

do it

 

[herdyrules]

Don't do it, that is a stupid trade. Brett Favre isn't in the top 10 in QBs out there. You can't just say he is cause he had a great game against a AWFUL defense. Steve Smith and the Panthers are flying high with Delhomme looking good and a great duo of RBs to fool the defense. They also have Mushin Muhmammad who has looked like a RC the last few weeks so they don't have to double cover Smith all the time.

Also who do you got for RBs??? You need WRs like Smith, Coles, and RW to compete.

 

[Official Aristocrat DJ ??]

I'd be all over that. Trade him!

 

[SQ180]

Here are my running backs: Peterson, McFadden, Felix Jones, DeAngelo Williams and Mewelde Moore

 

[Johan Santana #57]

i think you can move the WR, Favre is gonna have to pass alot if their D plays the way it has been playing

plus, the different between top WR and anohter option probably isn't too great

Every year Ive had smith hes screwed me so I might be bias lol

 

[herdyrules]

I'm go and try to combo one of your RBs and maybe either Gage or Gonzalez for a better QB.

 

[ctkenjr]

Trade him, but again it sort of depends on points from QBs, my league the int's **** QBs and Favre likes to throw to the opposing team a fair amount too.