Football CBS Sportsline Top 50 NFL Players.

[#11 Roy Williams]

Brett Favre, Champ Bailey, Carson Palmer, National Football League - CBS SportsLine.com

I think the list is pretty off.

Andre Johnson #14? Especially in front of Frank Gore, Steven Jackson, Steve Smith, etc.

Plus, alot of players aren't even on the list. Zach Thomas should definatly be on there, as well as Brian Dawkins. Not too mention, if Lee Evans is on the list, Roy Williams should be on there.

 

[Rukkus]

Actually its pretty accurate. Only reason Alexander was left off is because he has been knicked up lately.
As for Roy Williams I think you have to be on a team that has won more than 8 games the last 2 seasons to be on the list. I could be wrong though.

 

[Autonut1]

Roy should definitely be on that list...Andre Johnson, and Palmer are too high in my opinion...

 

[Jmac05]

No cornerback not named Deion Sanders should be that high. Champ is great, but he doesn't change the game that much.

 

[lilsss19]

Wow no Favre. Not a single Packer on that list. And Kevin Williams is on the list! I dont think this is real

 

[lafastbreak]

No cornerback not named Deion Sanders should be that high. Champ is great, but he doesn't change the game that much.

Champ Bailey was spectacular last season. He covered everyone.

 

[ljmaya]

I think the CBS in CBS Sportsline should stand for "Can't Be Serious"
As far as my outrages on this list in the top 25:
Carson Palmer please McNair is a better all-around QB than Palmer any day of the week.
Champ Bailey #4 no way. He is good but not #4 good. Especially in fantasy drafts who picks a DB with their first pick?
Shawne Merriman over Urlacher come on. Merriman was suspended 4 games last year.
Marvin Harrison middle of the pack? He should be top 15 for sure.

As far as other people deserving to be on the list: R. Bush, M. Jones-Drew, Thomas Jones, and Terrell Owens.

Lon

 

[5foot1Howard12]

WOW! that is wayyyy off. Nnamdi Asomugha, Kerry Rhodes, and Shawn Andrews are in da top 50, but yet BRIAN WESTBROOK, SHAUN ALEXANDER, TROY POLAMALU, AND REGGIE BUSH arent??? thats whack.

 

[5foot1Howard12]

sorry, but i just noticed madden 08 cover boy wasnt even listed anywhere, top 50 OR just missed.

 

[#11 Roy Williams]

That whole list is pretty messed. Johnson is on there, but Roy isn't. Roy had a better year in all categories.

I wouldn't really expect Bush and Vince Young to be on there because they have only played one year. But that list absolutely *****.