Baseball Pete Rose to Cooperstown?

Does Pete Rose Posthumously Get Inducted into Cooperstown?

  • Yes

    Votes: 11 73.3%

  • No

    Votes: 4 26.7%
  • Total voters
    15
kclj520

kclj520

If He Can Hold The World, He Can Hold This Moment
Staff member
Transactions
36
5.00 star(s)
Let's get some discussion going about this topic, as Pete himself has said on numerous occasions that he thinks baseball will induct him after his passing. I think if we have inducted people who were racists, womanizers, steroid users, and everyone in between, Pete being a gambler (among other things!) shouldnt overshadow his contributions to baseball for 24 seasons.

Thoughts??
 
grapler135s said:
Agreed! I'll bet he gets in now.
Click to expand...
@grapler135s

Its kind of a sad comment on the partiality of the Hall, but I have a lot of thoughts on some people who have gotten in, questionable at best!

@darkman

Totally agree, I mean, it was 30+ years ago that he was gambling on the Reds, baseball should have long ago moved past that!
 
They have no problem displaying his memorabilia there...there were 3 or 4 of his items on display this summer when my son and I visited. Definitely interesting that they would have his helmet, cleats, etc., but not his plaque.
 
grapler135s said:
They have no problem displaying his memorabilia there...there were 3 or 4 of his items on display this summer when my son and I visited. Definitely interesting that they would have his helmet, cleats, etc., but not his plaque.
Click to expand...
@grapler135s

I noticed that when we visited in 2019, found that to be pretty ironic. Kind of like Schilling 's bloody sock from 2004....it says "closest you are gonna get!"
 
Pete kept himself out of the Hall. It wasn't in him to be contrite or humble. He would already be in if he had listened to the many people who tried to help him.

I'm sad for his passing. I'm sad he did not get his ceremony, but now MLB can do the right thing because he, his worst enemy, is no longer his obstacle.

RIP Hit King.
 
BarJack34 said:
Pete kept himself out of the Hall. It wasn't in him to be contrite or humble. He would already be in if he had listened to the many people who tried to help him.

I'm sad for his passing. I'm sad he did not get his ceremony, but now MLB can do the right thing because he, his worst enemy, is no longer his obstacle.

RIP Hit King.
Click to expand...

@BarJack34

That is a great observation about Pete being his own worst enemy and main obstacle to the Hall of Fame. I think he sort of thew it in everyone's face, later profiting from the sale of his signature and inscribing "I'm sorry I bet on baseball" and selling copies of his court documents, etc. Your statement about how "now MLB can do the right thing because he, his worst enemy, is no longer his obstacle" is SPOT ON, very well said my friend!

I too am sorry about his sudden passing; my friend in Nashville just told me that he had appeared at a card show there over the weekend, so it must have been quite unexpected.

Cheers!

Kevin
 
Give it another 10 years when all his contemporaries die off & ownership changes there will be enough Rose fans that are owners to at least put it to a vote.
 
Waltdii said:
Give it another 10 years when all his contemporaries die off & ownership changes there will be enough Rose fans that are owners to at least put it to a vote.
Click to expand...

@Waltdii

I do think it will take some time, like you said, hopefully sooner rather than later. I found these two custom HOF plaques that various designers had created, cool items to help envision what his actual plaque in Cooperstown might look like!
Rose 1.jpg
Untitled.jpg
 
Pete Rose knew the rules of baseball. Then, after he was busted, he thumbed his nose at baseball's authority by admitting he bet on baseball. Here's a hard no on him ever getting in the Hall of Fame.
 
I personally think he should get in, but looking at the stance of the HOF I don’t think he gets in.

Joe Jackson never got in, so I don’t think Pete gets in either.
 
@bfd13
@Prosefan1
@dashcol

While he did thumb his nose at the establishment, I think that was part of his arrogance, which is what kept him out for so long....now that he has passed, time will tell if he gets in or not. Definitely a polarizing figure and there is a strong case for yes, and a strong case for no.
 
kclj520 said:
@bfd13
@Prosefan1
@dashcol

While he did thumb his nose at the establishment, I think that was part of his arrogance, which is what kept him out for so long....now that he has passed, time will tell if he gets in or not. Definitely a polarizing figure and there is a strong case for yes, and a strong case for no.
Click to expand...
He should be in. All times hit leader not if the HOF is a disgrace to me.

However, like I said, no player who has been proven to bet against the game has been allowed in, no matter how many years it is past their death.

Until MLB and the HOF change their stance on the betting of baseball, they will not get in.

It’s even worse to me when greats like Joe Jackson and Pete Rose are kept out, but they push gambling platforms at every game and encourage you to gamble, but you better not be a player! Maybe just ban players from betting against their team. Anything else is fair game.
 
Back
Top