Football Who is worse in december romo or eli?

[phillysports34579]

Who is worse in december Eli Manning or Tony Romo? (in their career so far)

 

[hector234]

This even really a question? It's Romo, Eli has a ring, Romo hasn't won a game in the post season

 

[phillysports34579]

i no my friend thought eli so i made a bet that people would say romo

 

[iLikePie]

Ho....i mean Romo.

 

[phillysports34579]

lol

 

[bigpapi4153]

I hate Eli but i think we all know the clear answer to this question is Romo.

 

[ewilkens]

This even really a question? It's Romo, Eli has a ring, Romo hasn't won a game in the post season

isn't the postseason in january?

I'm trying to think, and off the top of my head I don't remember Eli having any great Decembers including the year they won the super bowl. Romo gets the pub, but Eli hasn't exactly been great in cold weather in his career

 

[ewilkens]

from pro-football-reference.com
........W L T Cmp Att Cmp% Yds TD Int Rate Y/G
Eli.... 11 13 0 383 726 52.8% 4335 24 22 69.3 180.6
Romo 7 11 0 303 500 60.6% 3387 17 19 76.3 188.2

so they're both under .500
Romo completed a higher %, but also threw more picks
However, Romo has the slight edge in both QB Rating and Yards per game.

I actually think Eli has been worse, now that I took the time to look it up. Again, Romo gets the pub b/c Dallas as a team has collapsed recently, and the Giants won a Super Bowl, but in reality neither QB has been good...

 

[Bluedevil19]

eli just beat romo

 

[Bluedevil19]

(in december)

 

[ewilkens]

eli just beat romo

the question was in their careers... not last week