this is dumb....but I can't make a decision...I need some help

[pgwtamu]

2007 ud sp threads matt moore signing day auto

for

2005 prestige draft picks charlie frye auto #ed to 50

maybe if I knew BV on these it would aide in my decision better, none have ended on ebay and I can't get an accurate comparison sale to go off of.....but I really think both have flip potential at some point, and thats all I would be picking up the moore for.....lmk what ya'll think

 

[sliqwill]

not worth postage...

Moore $12

Frye $40

 

[bamasa37sb34]

I'd rather have the Moore.....Frye is probably done.

 

[oregonweim]

I'd rather have the Moore.....Frye is probably done.

this

 

[Poopy Pants]

Frye is 40 and Moore is 12. The highest card in the Singing Day set is Trent Edwards at 80. The next highest are Dwayne Bowe, Patrick Willis, and Selvin Young at 25. The highest cards in the Prestige set are Alex Smith, Aaron Rodgers, Ronnie Brown and Braylon Edwards at 100 each. Frye is on the Raiders, and would be behind Russell and Garcia at the least. Maybe even Andrew Walter. Moore is on the Panthers, and is behind Delhomme and McCown. As far as potential goes, I think Moore has more, but I dont think either will be more than backups.

 

[GiantFan]

doesn't really matter that much. Whatever one you want more.

 

[oregonweim]

Frye is 40 and Moore is 12. The highest card in the Singing Day set is Trent Edwards at 80. The next highest are Dwayne Bowe, Patrick Willis, and Selvin Young at 25. The highest cards in the Prestige set are Alex Smith, Aaron Rodgers, Ronnie Brown and Braylon Edwards at 100 each. Frye is on the Raiders, and would be behind Russell and Garcia at the least. Maybe even Andrew Walter. Moore is on the Panthers, and is behind Delhomme and McCown. As far as potential goes, I think Moore has more, but I dont think either will be more than backups.

definately true, although I think Moore is above McCown, could be mistaken...

 

[Poopy Pants]

definately true, although I think Moore is above McCown, could be mistaken...

I just looked on yahoo depth charts. He may be, but I just took what was on the site.

 

[pgwtamu]

thanks for your help guys....

 

[northcutt_fan]

Gradkowski & McCown > Moore & Frye ...

 

[pgwtamu]

man I think matt moore is going to be good.....he played pretty well when he did play...