Rank the 2009 NFL Card Products so far...

[sffanmike25]

So it's October now, and a decent number of products are now out, how do you like them so far based on what you collect?

Rank 'em 1-10, 1-5, whatever. I think I listed the majority of them, but if you liked something else, add it in as you go.

UD
Upper Deck
Upper Deck Draft
Upper Deck Heroes
Philadelphia
SPX

Panini
Prestige
Elite
Classics
Score
Leaf Rookies and Stars
Threads
Absolute Memorabilia

Topps
Topps Hobby Edition
Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects
Topps Magic
Topps Chrome
Bowman Sterling

Press Pass
Press Pass (Regular)
Press Pass SE
Press Pass Legends

Sage
Sage Hit
Sage Auto Edition

 

[sffanmike25]

My top 7, not to get lost in the shuffle of the long original post:

1) Press Pass Legends
2) Absolute Memorabilia
3) Topps Chrome
4) Leaf Rookies and Stars
5) Threads
6) Elite
7) Philadelphia

 

[bamasa37sb34]

My favorites so far:

Absolute
PP Legends
Magic
UD Draft

Philadelphia looks great, but failed to put in Glen Coffee, Rashad Johnson, or JPW. That hurt that product big time IMO

 

[Chicagobears34]

I haven't really done anything with cards since the summer, but I recently started trading again and The topps magic cards set looks good.

 

[Tazz]

You forgot UD Icons.
Hate Absolute for pulling Owen Daniels from most of the product.
I like Magic, Donruss Rookies/Stars, and Bowman Draft.

 

[northcutt_fan]

Topps Magic is nice.

 

[scotsman]

Magic, Absolute, Philadelphia for the on-card autos. Not enough experience of the others to rank.
However SPX looks the worst by a country mile.

 

[seahawks4ever]

Magic, Absolute, Philadelphia for the on-card autos. Not enough experience of the others to rank.
However SPX looks the worst by a country mile.

I could not believe the "X-factor" auto set in SPX. Jordan Kent is in it and he didn't even make the team. :doh:

I think UD decided to dump their extra auto stickers into a $170/box product. Way to go UD.

 

[scotsman]

I could not believe the "X-factor" auto set in SPX. Jordan Kent is in it and he didn't even make the team. :doh:

I think UD decided to dump their extra auto stickers into a $170/box product. Way to go UD.

It makes you wonder how they managed to get together such a great auto set in Philadelphia signatures? I wonder if they half-inched it (pinched/stole for the non-Cockneys) from Panini?

 

[northcutt_fan]

I saw Xfactor and thought it was Xfractor when doing my eBay search for JJ :wall: ...