Football Need Input On Trade

[joshvp3]

person A recieves:
2004 Peyton Manning topps dp&p qb legacy auto bv100
2006 chad johnson absoulute patch bv 20
Person B recieves:
2006 Tony Dorsett exquisite jersey auto/25 bv80
2006 Ladanian Tomlison gridiron gear patch/47

OR this trade
Person A recieves
Tyrus Thomas sp authentic rc auto/299
Person B recieves
Tony Dorsett exquisite bv80'


Need to know whatcha think

 

[RZ11]

..............

 

[bhelser]

I would take B on both

 

[RZ11]

Yea, I have to change what I said...I didn't see that the Dorsett was an auto....thought it was just a patch.

I would want the Dorsett over any of the other cards.

 

[balance13]

i'd also take B in both

 

[buitien]

I would take B in both.