I was right. After about 6 emails back and forth with PSA they admitted I am right. This IS NOT a 2011 is but in fact a 2015 mini buyback. Say hello to one of my favorite cards right now.
BTW, I really like the newest label from PSA and hate photobucket.
I guess they thought the mini card inside the frame determined the year it should have been labeled as? For as much as they know about the hobby, they have a heck of a lot to learn about modern subset identification.