Does $360 sound good for this?

bamasa37sb34

Bench Warmer
Thinking about making an offer of $360 to a guy for the following DeMeco Ryans cards, payable by December 31:

TWO National Treasures autos #/25
National Treausures auto #/25 Graded 8.5
Triple Threads Plate jersey/auto 1/1
Leaf Limited Monikers auto Graded 8.5
Leaf Limited Monikers auto Graded 9.0
Elite Status #/35 8.5
Elite TOTC Auto #/100 Graded 8.5
Elite Aspirations #/65 Graded 8.5
Elite Status auto #/24
Leaf Rookies and Stars auto #/10 graded 9
Leaf Rookies and Stars #/10 Graded 9.5
Leaf Rookies and Stars #/29 Graded 9.5
Topps Triple Threads Jersey/Auto #/10
SP Authentic #/25 Graded 9
Ultimate Collection Gold auto #/10
Flair Showcase auto Graded 9
Hot Prospects Red auto #/50 Graded 8.5
Bowman Chrome Orange #/25 Graded 9

Given those cards, how does that offer sound. High? Low? Seems reasonably to me, but would like to get opinions befor submitting an offer to the guy with the cards. Thanks!
 

bamasa37sb34

Bench Warmer
I didnt know Demeco sold so low.

Weird, ain't it? He's a beast on defense, but since he's a Texan, he sells pretty low. The thing that completely throws me through a loop on a deal is the graded cards. Never bought a graded card, nor do I know what kind of value they bring.
 

andy

Collector Planet Original
Transactions: 2
The grades are mute. 2 9.5s but drained out by a lot of 9s and 8.5s (which often sell worse than raw)
 

bamasa37sb34

Bench Warmer
The grades are mute. 2 9.5s but drained out by a lot of 9s and 8.5s (which often sell worse than raw)

Andy, most of the 8.5 cards, particularly the NT and LL cards are thick and are grade sensitive due to chipping on the edges.

So with this considered, would you think $360 is a good offer?
 

andy

Collector Planet Original
Transactions: 2
Andy, most of the 8.5 cards, particularly the NT and LL cards are thick and are grade sensitive due to chipping on the edges.

So with this considered, would you think $360 is a good offer?
I think in an auction it would go less but I might take this just because its a great opp to pickup some quantity of great stuff.
 

jaymix79

Bench Warmer
Are you buying these from a guy in Al? If not there was a guy that brought a ton of Ryan cards to the show here. He had a bunch of 9.5's! But he wanted alot for them.
 

bamasa37sb34

Bench Warmer
Are you buying these from a guy in Al? If not there was a guy that brought a ton of Ryan cards to the show here. He had a bunch of 9.5's! But he wanted alot for them.

The guy I'm trying to make a deal with is from Texas. Did the guy at that show have mostly Contenders, Ultimate, and NT cards? If so, I know the guy you are talking about.
 
R

rob4bama

Guest
I think the guy your buying from is getting a good deal. Your offer seems very fair to me. If the seller is that ew-guy, his buy-it-now prices are often WAY too high.
 

bamasa37sb34

Bench Warmer
I think the guy your buying from is getting a good deal. Your offer seems very fair to me. If the seller is that ew-guy, his buy-it-now prices are often WAY too high.

Yep, they are pretty rediculous.....hopefully he likes the offer :dance:

BTW, I've been watching some of the Darbys you've bid on recently....insane stuff :shock:
 

jaymix79

Bench Warmer
The guy I'm trying to make a deal with is from Texas. Did the guy at that show have mostly Contenders, Ultimate, and NT cards? If so, I know the guy you are talking about.

Yea that is him. He said he had all of the 9.5's of one brand or something. One of the high dollar brands. Nice guy though! Just dont need 100 Ryan auto's:roflmao:
 

northcutt_fan

Week old post bumping extraordinaire
Seems high to me, but then again, I collect Northcutt. I'd offer $300 and go from there.

Good luck, Stephen :roflmao:


:salut:
 
Top